Search

  • main dish
  • breakfast
  • dessert
  • Salads & Sides
  • Snacks & Appetizers
  • vegan
    • Bloglovin
    • Email
    • Facebook
    • Instagram
    • Pinterest
    • Twitter

Dietitian Debbie Dishes

Dishing Up Healthy, Vegetarian Eats

  • Meet Debbie
    • Work with Me
    • Privacy Policy
  • Recipes
    • Main Dishes
    • Breakfast
    • Desserts
    • Beverages
    • Salads & Sides
    • Snacks & Appetizers
    • gluten-free
    • vegan
  • nutrition
  • Spring

nutrition

Juices vs. Smoothies

Juices vs SmoothiesAccording to CDC, the majority of us in the US don’t get enough fruits and vegetables in our diet. In fact, they found that overall only 13% of people are meeting the 1-1.5 cups of fruit daily recommendation and 8.9% met the 2-3 cups of vegetables per day recommendation. One common way people try to increase their fruit and vegetable intake for the day is to simply whip up a smoothie or grab a green juice from the store. However, are juices and smoothies the best option for upping your intake of fruits and vegetables?

JUICES

Juicing means that you are simply squeezing out the nutrients and water from a fruit or vegetable and discarding the fiber. When chosen carefully, juices can be option for adding some of the nutrients from fruits and vegetables into your diet. However, I wouldn’t completely rely on juice to meet the total daily recommendation since they are lacking in fiber and aren’t very filling. Try to limit or avoid regular fruit juice since it such a concentrated source of sugar. Instead, experiment with vegetable based juices from juice bars or make your own at home. Also, be wary of juice “cleanses”. There’s no need to exist on juice only for 3-7 days to detox, instead incorporate a green juice once or twice a week into a balanced diet focused on unprocessed foods.  

  • PROS: Freshly made vegetable based juices can be as vitamin and mineral dense (sometimes more) as a smoothie. They are also a concentrated source of all the cancer fighting phytonutrients from the plants. View your green juice as a way to supplement a healthy diet with a dose of extra nutrients. Since juices lack fiber and protein, they are more quickly digested, which is why it is important limit too much sugar in your juices to prevent a blood sugar roller coaster. 
  • CONS: Juices lack fiber and protein. If you aren’t careful, they can also be a major source of sugar in your diet so aim to incorporate a higher ratio of vegetables to fruit in a juice. A healthy ratio I tend to use is about 80% vegetables to 20% fruit. Juice can be a bit pricey since you usually have to use a higher volume of produce to make a juice rather than a smoothie, which is why I typically limit them to 1-2x/week. You should also drink fresh juice soon after it was made as you can lose some of the nutrients due to oxidation over time. 

Juices vs. Smoothies | Dietitian Debbie Dishes

SMOOTHIES

Smoothies are an easy way to incorporate more fruits and vegetables into your day. Since everything is simply pureed, you still keep all of the healthy fiber from the produce. Like juices, smoothies can also be loaded with sugar if you aren’t careful. Smoothies can be filling, so they can be used as a meal, unlike juices which should supplement a healthy breakfast. 

  • PROS: All the healthy fiber from the fruits and vegetables is maintained which helps with satiety. Smoothies are usually a good source of protein as well as opposed to juices since you can incorporate milk, yogurt, nut butters, and more. For those who don’t like the flavor of vegetables, adding greens to a smoothie may be an option as it can mask the bitter flavors. 
  • CONS: Too many sugary ingredients in your smoothie could turn a healthy option into an un-healthy option. Instead of loading up on lots of fruit or fruit juice, make sure to also incorporate some protein (yogurt) and a vegetable (beets).  

Bottom Line

Choose a smoothie when you are looking for a healthy meal that you can easily take with you on-the-go in the morning. Add a green juice to your normal breakfast once or twice a week to reap the benefits of the extra vitamins and minerals. Don’t depend on healthy juices and smoothies to “fix” an unhealthy diet. They only work if you use them to supplement a healthy diet that incorporates lots of fruits, vegetables, plant based proteins, healthy fats, nuts, and seeds.

Check back next week for my new favorite, blender-made green juice! For some great smoothie inspiration, check out some of my favorite smoothie recipes:

  • Berry Beet Smoothie
  • Ginger Berry Smoothie
  • Strawberry Pineapple Green Smoothie


5 Comments

Sign up for my newsletter!

FREE healthy 7-day vegetarian meal plan when you sign up!

« Cucumber Watermelon Margarita
Eggplant Lasagna Rolls »

Comments

  1. Lauren @ Eating with a Purpose says

    August 11, 2015 at 11:53 am

    What a great post! This is a question I get asked on almost a daily basis by clients- thanks for clearing things up for others- definitely will be sharing this 🙂

    Reply
  2. Melanie says

    August 11, 2015 at 4:42 pm

    Great explanation of the pros and cons of both and how juices aren’t a good meal replacement!

    Reply
  3. Jessica @ Nutritioulicious says

    August 11, 2015 at 11:51 pm

    Great explanation of a commonly asked question!

    Reply
  4. Kalee @ The Crowded Table says

    August 12, 2015 at 2:42 am

    Great post! I have a few people in mind who really need to read this 🙂

    Reply
  5. Alex says

    May 30, 2018 at 10:28 am

    Thanks a lot, Debie! I’m glad you cleared this out since many people are confusing these two.

    I’d like to add that smoothies aren’t suggested for juice fasting. When someone is on a juice fasting detox program, the goal is to skip the digestion completely, so fiber is not welcome.

    Thanks again and keep it up!

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

About Me

I’m Debbie, the Registered Dietitian and writer behind this blog where you’ll find healthy, seasonal, vegetarian recipes! I believe that healthy eating and good nutrition shouldn’t be complicated so let me make it a little easier for you.

Search

Subscribe to my newsletter!

FREE healthy 7-day vegetarian meal plan when you sign up!

Quick and Easy Dinner Ideas

Spring Recipes

lemon raspberry smoothie

Lemon Raspberry Smoothie

White Bean Pesto Salad with Arugula

White Bean Pesto Salad with Arugula

Vegan Lemon Blueberry Baked Oatmeal

Vegan Lemon Blueberry Baked Oatmeal

vegan broccoli cheddar quiche

Vegan Broccoli Cheddar Quiche

strawberry spinach salad with lemon poppyseed dressing

Strawberry Spinach Salad with Lemon Poppyseed Dressing

Strawberry Rhubarb Overnight Oats | Healthy, Easy Breakfast that is perfect for busy weeks!

Overnight Oats with Strawberry Rhubarb Compote

Search

Copyright © 2022 · Divine theme by Restored 316

Copyright © 2022 · Divine Theme on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in · PRIVACY POLICY